Thursday, December 8, 2011

S&P 500 Revenues and Margins

Do you recall what the bears were saying about the earnings-led bull market during 2009 and 2010? They fought it all the way up as the S&P 500 increased 101.6% from a closing low of 676.53 on March 9, 2009 to a high, so far, of 1363.61 on April 29. The Naysayers dismissed the dramatic rebound in earnings as unsustainable. They claimed that it was all based on cost cutting, which couldn’t continue for very long. They predicted that revenue growth would be subpar, at best. So let’s see what actually happened using data we compiled on forward revenues, earnings, and profit margins for the S&P 500 and its 10 sectors in our new publication titled S&P 500 Sector Squiggles: Revenues, Earnings, and Margins. 

S&P 500 forward revenues did decline by 6.1% during 2009, while forward earnings rose 0.3% as the forward profit margin rose from 7.7% at the start of the year to 8.4% by the end of the year. But in 2010, forward revenues rose 7.1%, which along with an increase in the profit margin to 9.6% at the end of last year, boosted forward earnings by 23.8%. Data available through early December show that revenues and earnings are up 7.8% and 11.7% so far this year, while the profit margin has stalled since the spring around 10%.

Looking into 2012, it’s hard to see much upside for these three variables. I expect that they will be flat. More specifically, revenues could average $1,050 a share, about the same as this year. The profit margin might edge down to 9.5%. The result would be earnings around $100, up slightly from about $97 this year.

The scenario behind these numbers is slower global growth, with Europe in a mild recession while the US economy continues to muddle along with real GDP growing around 2%.

Wednesday, December 7, 2011

S&P 500 and Industrial Commodity Prices

One of the best ways to assess whether the global economy is progressing and regressing on a real-time basis is to track the CRB raw industrials spot price index. It includes the prices of 13 industrial commodities. I like it because it excludes petroleum and lumber products, which have their own unique supply and demand fundamentals. The index is highly correlated with global industrial production and global exports. (See Figures 1 and 2 in our High Frequency Economic Indicators.)

The CRB index is also highly correlated with the overall S&P 500, especially with its Transportation index. Indeed, this commodity price index is one of the three components of our Fundamental Stock Market Indicator (FSMI), which has an especially tight fit with the S&P 500 (Figure 55). The message from these sensitive indicators is that the global economy remains relatively weak:

(1) As of yesterday, the CRB raw industrials spot price index (1967 = 100) was 527.4, down 17.3% from its record high of 638.1 on April 12. However, it remains just above its previous cyclical peak of 525.7 on May 13, 2008, and 66.7% above its previous cyclical low of 316.3 on December 5, 2008.

(2) Our Boom Bust Barometer (BBB)--which is the ratio of the CRB index to the four-week moving average of initial unemployment claims--was 133.9 at the end of November, which is 16.1% below the most recent cyclical peak of 159.6 on March 12, 2011 and 14.4% below the prior cyclical peak on August 11, 2007 (Figure 54).

(3) Our FSMI--which averages our BBB and Bloomberg’s weekly Consumer Comfort Index--edged down at the end of November to 91.9. It is 15.5% below its most recent cyclical peak on February 26, 2011. It suggests that the S&P 500 should be trading between 1150 and 1200 (Figure 55).

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

S&P 500/400/600 Forward Earnings & Factory Orders

Industry analysts who cover the S&P 1500 either didn’t receive or didn’t read the European recession memo. European economies are heading down, according to November’s purchasing managers indexes (PMIs) for the euro zone and the UK. Emerging economies--including Brazil and China--are showing some signs of stress too, which most likely reflect their weakening exports to Europe, as well as the depressing impact of previous tightening of their monetary policies.

Yet, in the US, forward earnings managed to rise to new record highs for the S&P 400 MidCaps and the S&P 600 SmallCaps during the week of December 2. The forward earnings of the S&P 500 remains in a record high flat trend, which started earlier this year. It is up for the fifth straight week to $107.18, the highest reading in eight weeks.

The V-shaped recovery that started in early 2009 for the forward earnings of all three market cap indexes may be over for the LargeCaps, but it seems to be resuming now after stalling earlier this year. This may be happening because LargeCaps tend to be more exposed to sales within Europe and exports to the region than smaller US companies, which are more highly leveraged to growth in the US.

Industry analysts are clearly giving more weight to signs of resilience in the US economy despite the weakening outlook for the global economy, particularly in Europe. The US purchasing managers’ surveys for both manufacturing and nonmanufacturing stood out during November with readings above 50. Most other PMI readings around the world were below this make-or-break level for economic growth. While it’s hard to imagine that the US can decouple from the weakening global trend, industry analysts are relatively sanguine about this prospect, for now. That could all change quickly if Europe’s recession gets much worst and if Europe’s credit crunch depresses economic activity beyond the region as European banks cut back on their global lending.

So while the resilience of the three measures of forward earnings is impressive, I should warn you that they also took last gasps in mid-2008. Then they keeled over during the second half of that year through early 2009 as the US financial crisis intensified, causing a severe global recession.

The flattening of the S&P 500’s forward earnings poses a risk to Industrials. There is a very tight relationship between S&P 500 forward earnings and new factory orders. Profitable companies expand, while unprofitable ones do not. So it isn’t surprising that total orders have stalled over the past three months through October around $5.4 trillion, at a seasonally adjusted annual rate, along with the forward earnings of the S&P 500.

On the other hand, nondefense capital goods orders, which are volatile on a m/m basis, remain on an uptrend, though they dropped in October, led by a sharp decline in civilian aircraft orders. Shipments of nondefense capital goods rose to a new cyclical high of $862.4 billion (saar) over the three months through October, with new orders for construction equipment jumping to a new record high during the month.

Monday, December 5, 2011

US Employment Indicators


The Birthers were quiet on Friday following the release of November’s payroll employment report. They usually get all hot and bothered about the so-called birth/death adjustment (BDA) to total payrolls. Whenever it is up, they claim that it is bogus and immediately subtract it from the total to demonstrate that the labor market is weaker than suggested by the headline employment number. They did that last month when the BDA added 102,000 to October’s payrolls, which showed a gain of 80,000 on a preliminary basis. November’s report showed that this adjustment reduced payrolls by 29,000. Yet the Birthers didn’t bray that the increase in payrolls must have been greater than the first-reported official estimate of 120,000.

The Birthers will be back as soon as the BDA is positive again, which won’t be long. The statistical model used by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) is “designed to reduce a primary source of non-sampling error which is the inability of the sample to capture, on a timely basis, employment growth generated by new business formations.” Even during 2008, 2009, and 2010 the BDA added 724,000, 477,000, and 288,000 to payrolls. By the way, that adjustment is added to the data before the total is seasonally adjusted. Yet the Birthers always make the serious mistake of comparing the seasonally unadjusted BDA to the seasonally adjusted total.

Friday’s employment report was mostly chock full of good news. However, there was some bad news too. Let’s review:

(1) All employment measures showed solid gains in November. Total nonfarm payrolls rose 120,000 and household employment jumped 278,000 during the month. Private-sector employment rose 140,000 according to the official release, while ADP reported a solid gain of 206,000. The irrelevance of the BDA issue is confirmed on a regular basis by the close correlation of the trend and magnitude of changes in the comparable BLS and ADP statistics. So for example, the private payrolls over the past 12 months have increased 1.88 million according to BLS and 1.86 million according to ADP. Household employment (which includes government workers) is up 1.67 million over this same period.

(2) The revisions in the previous two months tend to be more important employment indicators than the preliminary estimate. I have long argued that more weight should be placed on those revisions than on the first reported estimate. The revisions tend to be upward during economic expansions and downward during recessions. September’s preliminary gain for total payroll employment has now been revised up twice by a total of 107,000 (from 103,000 to 158,000 to 210,000). October’s estimate has been revised up once by 20,000 (from 80,000 to 100,000), and will likely be revised upward again when December payroll data are released on January 6. Over the past 12 months through October, revisions have boosted payrolls by 326,000 (231,000 the past three months).  

(3) Total hours worked rose to a new cyclical high during November. The index of aggregate weekly hours in private industries edged up 0.1% during the month, despite a 0.5% downtick in manufacturing, which seems a bit odd, given the strength in industrial production.

(4) The evidence on part-time vs. full-time jobs is mixed. The household survey shows that full-time employment increased by 323,000 during November to a new cyclical high of 113.1 million. That’s still 8.7 million below the record high of 121.8 million during November 2007. Part-time employment fell 91,000 during the month, and remains near recent record highs. During November, nearly 20% of household employment was part time.

The payroll data show that the temporary help services industry increased headcount by 22,300 during November. Other industries that tend to rely on part-time workers also expanded during November, with retail and leisure & hospitality jobs up 49,800 and 22,000, respectively, during the month. Over the past 24 months, the temporary help service industry added 484,000 employees, accounting for 21.4% of the gain in total payroll employment.

(5) The pace of hiring is improving, but the pace of firing remains elevated. The latest available JOLTS data through September show that the pace of hiring rose during the month to the highest in 16 months. On a 12-month basis, total hiring started to exceed total separations during September 2010 for the first time since the spring of 2008. Over the past 12 months through September, total hires were 48.0 million and total separations were 46.7 million, yielding an employment gain of 1.3 million.

This improvement in hiring activity is consistent with the Monster Employment Index, a measure of online job ads. This index has been trending higher all year. However, it did dip slightly during November, but remained at the third highest reading of this year. All of the major industries included in the index were flat to down during November with the exception of Transportation and Warehouses, which climbed to a new high for the series going back to 2003. While initial unemployment claims rose back above 400,000 during the week of November 26 (402,000), the four-week average was 395,750 during that week.

(6) The bad news is that wage gains aren’t keeping up with inflation. The good news is that the falling real cost of labor should continue to boost employment. Average hourly earnings for all workers rose 1.8% y/y through November. Over the same period, we estimate that the CPI rose 3.6%. So there has been an erosion of purchasing power for workers. In the past, real pay per worker tended to be highly correlated with productivity. Recently, there has been a divergence as productivity continues to grow rapidly. That’s certainly boosted corporate profits, which in turn may be starting to boost employment. My mantra: “Jobs are created by profitable companies, not by government programs.”

Thursday, December 1, 2011

US Employment & Confidence Indicators

Yesterday’s ADP report on private-sector payroll employment during November was magnificent. No wonder that consumer confidence rebounded during the month. Chicago’s purchasing managers also had good things to say about business activity in their neighborhood. The evidence continues to demonstrate the resilience of the US economy. It’s doing remarkably well despite all the loco commotion in Europe and Washington. Let’s review the latest batch of happy data:

(1) This may be the third “new normal” jobless recovery in a row that’s starting to morph into an old normal recovery. Sure enough, November’s gain of 206,000 payroll jobs in the private sector, as reported by ADP, is the kind of gain that could start lowering the unemployment rate if it continues. The ADP report was chock full of good news, including an upward revision in October’s gain from 110,000 to 130,000. Especially impressive is that 53% of November’s new jobs were created by small businesses with under 50 employees. Note to Washington: Government doesn’t create jobs; small businesses do as they grow into bigger businesses. Just don’t get in their way.

(2) November’s bounce in consumer confidence confirms that the labor market is improving. The Consumer Confidence Index rebounded 15.1 points during November to 56.0 from 40.9 during October. It was the biggest m/m rebound since April 2003. This index tends to give more weight to consumers’ assessment of the labor markets than the Consumer Sentiment Index, which increased 3.2 points during November.

(3) Chicago’s purchasing managers are showing thumbs up. Chicago’s Institute for Supply Management yesterday reported that its business barometer increased to 62.6 in November from 58.4 the prior month as orders and production strengthened. The group's production gauge increased to a seven-month high of 67.3 from 63.4. Their new orders index rose to 70.2, the highest since March, from 61.3. Manufacturing in the Midwest is benefiting from rising auto sales and the strength in demand for capital goods at home and abroad.