Sunday, October 30, 2011

European Central Bank


How did German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French President Nicolas Sarkozy (“Merkozy”) manage to convert a really scary story into a happy tale that has been so wildly bullish for stocks and commodities during the month that ends with Halloween? That’s a very good question.

Perhaps the simplest explanation is that investors have concluded that the latest Grand Plan to save the euro fashioned by Merkozy is just as flawed as the one that was dead on arrival on July 21. So the inevitable solution to the Euro-Mess is to have the ECB clean it all up.

In other words, the mantra in financial markets is now, “Ease, Mario, ease!” Last week, in the October 25 FT, Martin Wolf led the chant in his column titled “Be bold, Mario, put out the fire.” He wants incoming ECB President Mario Draghi to implement a program of quantitative easing. The only problem is that Article 123 of the Treaty of Lisbon (2007) prohibits the ECB from doing just that.

Nevertheless, the ECB has started doing it again for a second time. The bank’s balance sheet rose to a record €2.3 trillion on October 21, up €440 billion from a 2011 low of €1.9 trillion on April 8. This expansion was attributable to the ECB increasing its loans to euro area financial institutions by €177 billion to €585 billion. In addition, the ECB’s holdings of euro area bonds rose €110 billion so far this year to a record €567 billion. In the ECB’s first round of QE, the bank’s balance sheet soared by €512 billion to €2.0 trillion during the four weeks through October 17, 2008.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

Home Alone: Update on the Homestead Act

Everyone knows that housing was the epicenter of the previous recession and that it is the biggest drag on the recovery. President Barack Obama wants to help by allowing homeowners to refinance their mortgages at record low interest rates even if the values of their homes have fallen below the amounts they owe.

The majority of the FOMC wants to help too. That’s why they voted to implement Operation Twist at their meeting on September 20-21, despite the objections of three cold-hearted dissenters. Last week and early this week, three of the do-gooders on the FOMC said they are ready to do more good and are considering a third round of quantitative easing that would include purchasing mortgage-backed securities again.

I don’t understand why no one in Washington is pushing for more targeted policies that would simply reduce the huge overhang of unsold homes. Doing so would take the downward pressure off of home prices. Actually, it should boost home prices by convincing would-be homebuyers to stop waiting for better deals and jump in and buy a house.

That’s the objective of the Homestead Act that Carl Goldsmith and I proposed this past summer. It would provide a matching down payment subsidy of up to $20,000 for anyone purchasing a home as their principal residence for two million houses. It would provide tax-free rental income for 10 years to anyone who purchases a house to rent for another one million houses. That would eliminate the current overhang of unsold homes completely.

Carl and I reached out to various political leaders in Washington on both sides of the aisle. Congressman Gary Ackerman liked the idea well enough to instruct his staff to work on a bill. The problem is that our plan would lower the corporate tax rate on repatriated earnings to 10%, using the proceeds to pay for the subsidy. The Congressional Budget Office scores these tax revenues as though they will be raised at the 35% tax rate even though such a high rate has been a major obstacle for such repatriation. So, we’ve hit a road block, though we are still pushing for the plan as best we can.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Confidence & the P/E

Everyone is very depressed. Investors are very depressed, as evidenced by the latest Bull/Bear Ratio, which is 1.06 this week. Although that’s the first reading above 1.00 in seven weeks, it’s still very low. Yet the S&P 500 is down only 2.3% ytd and 9.9% from the year’s high on April 29. Consumers are also very depressed. Yesterday, the Conference Board released October’s Consumer Confidence Index (CCI), which plunged during the month to 39.8 from 46.4 in September. It is the lowest since March 2009. The expectations component fell to 48.7 from 55.1 last month. Yet retail sales have been remarkably resilient.

There is a close correlation between the forward P/E of the S&P 500 and the expectations component of the CCI. They have fluctuated in volatile cycles since 2008, rising together in response to the Fed’s numerous attempts to make things better, but then falling together on disappointment over the results. Unemployment remains high. Inflation-adjusted incomes are stagnant. Home prices are depressed. Profits are great, but the European financial crisis increases the risk of a global slowdown or even a double dip.

Yet employment is growing, though at a lackluster pace. Home prices have mostly stopped falling. Energy prices are down from elevated levels at the beginning of the year. Borrowing costs are at record lows. Many business managers seem to be moving forward, and not letting the constant meddling of our political leaders get in the way of doing business.

The P/E rebounded during October as investors regained some of their confidence in the resiliency of the US economy. It also rebounded on hope that the Europeans would muddle along and avoid a financial meltdown. There should be more upside in the valuation multiple as long as investors expect that muddling will prevail over melting. That’s likely to be the case over the rest of the year. On the other hand, the upside for the P/E may be limited if consumers remain as depressed as they were in October. Are we having fun yet?

Tuesday, October 25, 2011

S&P 500 Earnings

We monitor quarterly and annual earnings expectations every Tuesday in our Morning Briefing. This is an especially interesting exercise during earnings seasons, allowing us to see how actual results are influencing future projections. Here is what has happened so far:

(1) During the week of October 21, the actual/estimated blend of earnings for the S&P 500 jumped to $24.91 per share from $24.43 the prior week. So the y/y growth rate rose from 12.3% to 14.5%. That jump was certainly boosted by a quirky accounting rule that lets banks book a profit on the falling value of their own debt. It accounted for nearly half of the profits gain for both Citi and JP Morgan Chase.

(2) The uptick in Q3 didn’t stop analysts from cutting their numbers for Q4 and all of 2012. The Q4 estimate was lowered to $25.38, which would be up 12.6% y/y. The 2012 estimate fell to $108.90, which would be up 11.5% from the latest estimate for 2011. Next year’s estimate has been lowered in 10 of the past 11 weeks.

(3) The V-shaped recovery in forward earnings, which powered the bull market since March 2009, is losing steam. Indeed, forward earnings has been flat for the past 10 weeks, with a slight downward tilt over the past six weeks.

Joe and I are still expecting that next year’s estimate will be lowered to $100 a share by the end of this year. Forward earnings will do the same since it is a time-weighted average of the current and coming year estimates.






Sunday, October 23, 2011

The Fed & QE

We need to find something for Fed officials to do in their spare time. They insist on subjecting the economy to their new experimental monetary policy fixes that are extremely controversial and replete with dangerous unintended consequences. They refuse to believe that they’ve run out of policy tools. They insist they can do more to revive economic growth and lower the unemployment rate. That’s despite lots of evidence that record low interest rates and a second round of quantitative easing haven’t stimulated growth as they expected.

Although they started to implement their Maturity Extension Program (MEP)--a.k.a. Operation Twist--just last month, they are already having second thoughts about it. Rather than cease and desist, they want to do more, including a third round of quantitative easing and more “forward policy guidance.” Let’s review the latest developments:

(1) The minutes of the September 20-21 FOMC meeting, which were released on October 12, suggested that QE-3.0 is still on the table: “A number of participants saw large-scale asset purchases as potentially a more potent tool that should be retained as an option in the event that further policy action to support a stronger economic recovery was warranted.”

(2) Last week, Fed Governor Daniel Tarullo, who rarely comments on monetary policy, made headlines with a speech he presented on Thursday, October 20 in which he said: “I believe we should move back up toward the top of the list of options the large-scale purchase of additional mortgage-backed securities (MBS), something the FOMC first did in November 2008 and then in greater amounts beginning in March 2009 in order to provide more support to mortgage lending and housing markets.” One of the many benefits of doing so, he said, is that it should induce “investors to shift to other assets, including bonds and equities.”

(3) The next day, in a speech on Friday, October 21, Fed Vice Chair Janet Yellen seconded Tarullo’s consideration of another round of QE. She noted that while the Fed had only just recently implemented Operation Twist, it is a program limited by the Fed’s holding of short-term securities, and buying most of the outstanding long-term Treasuries might not be such a good idea after all since it “could potentially have adverse effects on market functioning.”

Wow, is she already admitting that MEP was a mistake?! I think she is. So what does she want to do instead? More, more! She’s ready for QE-3.0: In her opinion, “securities purchases across a wide spectrum of maturities might become appropriate if evolving economic conditions called for significantly greater monetary accommodation.”
 
Apparently, Ms. Yellen doesn’t have any doubts about the effectiveness of quantitative easing despite plentiful evidence that QE-2.0 actually backfired. The chart above shows inflation-adjusted retail sales since 2008. After recovering solidly from September 2009 through November 2010, it’s been flat since then through September of this year.

In my opinion, after QE-2.0 was first mentioned by Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke on August 27, 2010 and actually implemented on November 3, 2010, it depressed the purchasing power of consumers by boosting food and fuel prices. QE-2.0 backfired. It clobbered consumer spending just as the economy was on the verge of transitioning to self-sustained expansion, without any help from the Fed.

Why did Fed officials rush to implement QE-2.0? They clearly failed to recognize that the soft patch in economic growth from May through July was temporarily related to the termination of tax incentives to buy houses and appliances at the end of April 2010. Despite having hundreds of economists working at the Fed, they completely misread the economy and meddled at the worst possible time. They seem intent on making the same mistake all over again now.
 
The second chart in our blog today shows the performance of the S&P 500 with overlays showing when QE-1.0, QE-2.0, and Operation Twist were in effect. Stock prices rallied during the first and second rounds of quantitative easing. They sold off as soon as both programs were terminated. They are rallying again under the influence of Operation Twist and talk of a third round of quantitative easing. Pushing up stock prices has been one of the main goals of the Fed’s experiments with untested monetary policy measures. How much longer will they succeed in boosting stock prices if they not only fail to boost economic growth, but actually adversely affect it?